Contact Us Utility navigation dividerSite Map

Agency-based Specialty Property

Contact American Reliable

Mailing Address

American Reliable Insurance Company
P.O. Box 4096
Scottsdale, AZ 85261


Policyholder Portal

  • Make a Payment and View Payment History
  • Manage Future Payments/Invoice Schedules
  • View & Print Policy Documents and Invoices

Telephone Numbers

General: 480.483.8666 or 800.535.1333


Fax Numbers

Admin: 480.998.3460
Claims: 800.224.4170
Personal Lines Underwriting: 480.483.0238
Marketing: 480.483.7704


Email Address

For general inquiries:


To contact personnel within all other departments, please select from the list below.

Randall Gardner, Director Accounting, ext. 1645

Christina Cama, Vice President - Human Resources, ext. 1618

Robert Hill, President, COO, ext. 1659

Stephen H. Graham, Vice President, Agriculture

Patricia Quint, Vice President, Claims, ext. 2607

Jeff Labe, Marketing Manager, ext. 7478

Curt Mang, Operations Manager, ext. 1679

Mike Taber, Operations MIS Manager, ext. 7469

Alicia Rogers, MIS Analyst, ext. 5077

Stephanie Mills, Operations Analyst, ext. 1682